What is the difference in expense ratios between SPYD and VYM, and why does this matter for long-term returns?

SPYD has an expense ratio of 0.07%, whereas VYM has a lower expense ratio of 0.04%. This 0.03 percentage point difference means VYM is cheaper to hold. Over long periods, lower fees can help preserve more of your capital, assuming other factors are equal. While the difference seems small, it compounds over time, impacting net returns. However, fees are only one consideration among many, including dividend yield and portfolio strategy, when evaluating exchange-traded funds.

How do the investment strategies of SPYD and VYM differ regarding index tracking?

SPYD tracks the S&P 500 High Dividend Index, focusing specifically on high-yield stocks within the S&P 500. In contrast, VYM tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index, which includes a broader range of large-cap US stocks with high dividend yields. Consequently, SPYD's universe is limited to the S&P 500 constituents, while VYM has wider market coverage. This structural difference leads to distinct holdings, risk profiles and sector exposures for each fund.

What does category classification indicate about the risk profiles of SPYD and VYM?

SPYD is classified as a Mid-Cap Value fund, while VYM is categorized as Large Value. This indicates differences in the market capitalisation and investment style of their underlying holdings. Mid-cap stocks generally offer a blend of growth potential and value characteristics, often with higher volatility than large-cap stocks. Large-cap value stocks, typical of VYM, are usually more established companies. Investors should consider these distinctions when assessing potential risk and return characteristics.

How similar are the top holdings between SPYD and VYM?

There is minimal overlap in the top holdings of SPYD and VYM. The only shared holding within their respective top 10 positions is Chevron Corporation (CVX). SPYD's top holdings include companies like HP Inc. (HPQ) and Accenture (ACN), while VYM is weighted towards Broadcom Inc. (AVGO) and JPMorgan Chase (JPM). This low degree of overlap suggests that the two funds follow fundamentally different selection criteria and portfolio construction methods, leading to diverse exposure across various sectors.

What are the dividend yields for SPYD and VYM, and how do they compare?

SPYD offers a dividend yield of 4.37%, while VYM provides a yield of 2.31%. SPYD's yield is significantly higher, reflecting its specific focus on high-dividend-paying stocks within the S&P 500. VYM's lower yield aligns with its broader large-cap strategy. High yields can be attractive for income seekers but may also signal higher risk or slower growth potential in some cases. Investors should weigh yield against the fund's overall strategy and stability when considering these options.

How do the net assets of SPYD and VYM influence their liquidity?

SPYD has net assets of $7.4 billion, while VYM manages $80.9 billion. VYM's larger asset base generally indicates higher liquidity and potentially tighter bid-ask spreads for traders. However, SPYD's size of $7.4 billion is still substantial and provides reasonable liquidity for most retail investors. Larger funds often benefit from economies of scale, which can keep expenses low. Asset size is a factor in liquidity but does not guarantee better investment performance or lower risk.

How do SPYD and VYM react to value versus growth market trends?

VYM, with a inception date of Nov 10, 2006, is a Large Value fund that often underperforms during periods of strong growth momentum but may outperform when value styles are favoured. SPYD, launched Oct 21, 2015, is a Mid-Cap Value fund focused on high dividends. While both lean towards value, SPYD's mid-cap exposure and higher yield focus mean it behaves differently than VYM. Their performance depends heavily on whether investors favour stable large-caps or income-generating mid-caps.

What are the potential risks associated with SPYD's high-dividend strategy?

SPYD's focus on high dividend yields within the S&P 500 introduces specific risks. The strategy is vulnerable to sector concentration, as high-yielding stocks often cluster in certain industries like utilities or real estate. Additionally, high yields can sometimes signal underlying financial distress or 'value traps' where prices fall faster than dividends are paid. The shorter track record since 2015 also means less historical data is available to assess its long-term resilience during market downturns compared to older funds.

Why is it important to consider inception dates when comparing ETFs?

VYM was launched on Nov 10, 2006, while SPYD began on Oct 21, 2015. The longer inception date for VYM provides nearly a decade more historical data on how the fund performs across various market cycles. This extensive track record can offer investors greater confidence in the strategy's long-term viability. SPYD's shorter history means less data is available to verify its performance, particularly during prolonged bear markets, which is a practical consideration for risk assessment.

What should beginners know before choosing between SPYD and VYM?

Beginners should understand that SPYD and VYM serve different primary goals. SPYD, with its 4.37% yield, is typically associated with higher current income strategies. VYM, yielding 2.31%, is often viewed as a more balanced approach to dividend growth and capital preservation in large-cap stocks. Neither fund is universally 'better'; the choice depends on whether an investor prioritises higher immediate cash flow or broader large-cap exposure. Always consider your personal risk tolerance and time horizon.

SPYD vs VYM

Two funds, one decision: we compare cost, performance and what each ETF actually holds in September 2026.

Compare SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 High Dividend ETF (SPYD) and Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM). This page reviews fees, holdings, dividends and how each fund tracks its market, highlighting their respective 0.07% and 0.04% expense ratios. Educational content, not financial advice.

Fund Snapshot

Key Fund Metrics

SPYD

Metric

VYM

0.07%

Expense Ratio

0.04%

4.37%

Dividend Yield

2.31%

$7.38B

Net Assets

$80.88B

Holdings

613

Oct 21, 2015

Inception Date

Nov 10, 2006

–

Index Tracked

–

Mid-Cap Value

Fund Category

Large Value

VYM costs about $3.00 less per year for every $10,000 invested.

Shared Top Holdings

Holding	SPYD	VYM
CVXChevron Corporation	1.43%	1.54%

Discover More Comparisons

SPYD vs VOO

Compare SPYD and VOO ETFs. Review expense ratios, dividend yields, and top holdings. SPYD yields 4.37%; VOO yields 1.03%. Factual analysis only.

SPYD vs SPYI

Compare SPYD and SPYI ETFs. Analyse expense ratios, dividend yields, holdings, and tracking methods. Review fund data, inception dates, and net assets.

SPYD vs SPYV

Compare SPYD and SPYV on fees, dividends, holdings and tracking. SPYD yields 4.37% with 0.07% expenses; SPYV yields 1.69% with 0.04% expenses.

Investment Analysis

SPYD

Pros

SPYD features a competitive expense ratio of 0.07%, helping to minimise ongoing investor costs.
The fund provides access to the S&P 500 with a focus on companies offering higher-than-average dividend yields.
SPYD has attracted substantial net assets of $7.4 billion, indicating reasonable investor demand and liquidity.

Considerations

The fund's high dividend yield strategy introduces greater vulnerability to sector concentration and value investing risks.
Individual holding weights are relatively small, with the largest position at 1.80%, diluting conviction in any single name.
Since its October 2015 inception, SPYD has a shorter track record compared to some established high-dividend competitors.

VYM

Pros

VYM boasts a significantly lower expense ratio of 0.04% alongside an immense asset base of $80.9 billion.
It offers broad, diversified exposure across large-cap US stocks focused on consistent above-average dividend payouts.
Launched in November 2006, the fund possesses an extensive track record, demonstrating long-term adherence to its strategy.

Considerations

The dividend yield of 2.31% is considerably lower than dedicated high-yield alternatives.
VYM maintains significant weightings in individual stocks like AVGO at 6.93% and JPM at 3.83%.
As a large-value strategy, VYM underperforms growth-focused equities during phases of strong market momentum.

About SPYD and VYM

SPYD (SPYD)

The SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 High Dividend ETF aims to track an index of U.S. companies within the S&P 500 that have relatively higher dividend yields. Designed for income-focused investors, it provides exposure to established companies often considered value-oriented. With a low expense ratio of 0.07%, this fund is cost-efficient for those seeking consistent income generation. It holds a diversified portfolio of approximately 81 securities, balancing risk across various sectors. Launched in October 2015, the fund has grown to net assets of $7.38 billion. Its current dividend yield is 4.37%, making it an attractive option for investors prioritising regular cash flow. However, as with any investment, capital values can fluctuate, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Suitable for long-term investors comfortable with equity risk.

VYM (VYM)

The Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF is designed to provide investors with exposure to a broad range of high-dividend-paying stocks listed in the US. With a low expense ratio of 0.04% and over 600 holdings, the fund aims to deliver income while maintaining diversification. Its dividend yield sits at 2.31%, reflecting its focus on companies with strong payout traditions. This ETF suits those seeking a steady income stream as part of a long-term strategy, though values can rise and fall. Returns are not guaranteed. Always consider your personal circumstances before investing.

Buy SPYD or VYM in Nemo

🆓

Zero Commission

Trade stocks, ETFs, and more with zero commission. Keep more of your returns.

🔒

Trusted & Regulated

Part of Exinity Group 2015, serving over a million customers globally.

💰

6% Interest on Cash

Earn 6% AER on uninvested cash with daily interest payments.

SPYD vs VYM

Fund Snapshot