What is the primary strategy behind these S&P 500 income ETFs?

Both GPIX and SPYI are categorised as Derivative Income ETFs. Unlike traditional index funds that simply hold stocks, these funds use options strategies, typically involving covered calls, to generate additional cash flow. The goal is to enhance income beyond standard dividends while attempting to remain correlated with the S&P 500. Investors should understand that this approach modifies the typical risk-return profile, often capping upside potential in exchange for current income generation, which is key for beginners interpreting these comparison metrics.

How do expense ratios impact the net returns of these funds?

The expense ratio is an annual fee deducted from a fund's assets. GPIX has an expense ratio of 0.29%, whereas SPYI's is 0.68%. This represents a 0.39 percentage point difference. Over time, lower fees can result in better net returns, all else being equal. While SPYI may offer a higher distribution rate, the higher cost serves as a drag on total return. Beginners should consider this fee gap when evaluating whether the additional income provided justifies the increased cost relative to the fund's performance.

What does it mean if the index tracked is not available for these ETFs?

For both GPIX and SPYI, the specific index tracked is not available in the provided data. Standard index funds aim to replicate a specific benchmark, but derivative income ETFs often manage portfolios actively or via proprietary formulas rather than strictly following a public index methodology. The lack of available index data suggests that their performance may deviate from the S&P 500 in unique ways. Investors must rely on the fund prospectuses and historical returns rather than a simple benchmark comparison to assess tracking accuracy.

Which fund offers a higher dividend yield and what are the figures?

SPYI provides a dividend yield of 11.79%, which is significantly higher than GPIX's yield of 8.07%. This difference of over 3.7 percentage points means SPYI distributes more cash to investors per share held, assuming other factors remain constant. High-yield ETFs like these are often popular with income-focused investors. However, it is essential to look beyond just the yield. The source of this yield, whether from corporate dividends or option premiums, and its sustainability vary, so a higher number does not automatically imply a superior investment outcome for every financial goal.

How do the top holdings of GPIX and SPYI compare in terms of overlap?

There is substantial overlap in the top holdings of both funds. The shared top-10 positions include NVDA, AAPL, MSFT, AMZN, GOOGL, AVGO, MU, META, and TSLA. Their weighting is also quite similar; for instance, NVDA is approximately 8.11% in GPIX and 8.14% in SPYI. This high degree of overlap suggests that both ETFs are closely mirroring the current composition of the S&P 500. Despite their derivative strategies, the underlying equity exposure remains anchored by the same large-cap technology and consumer discretionary giants, indicating comparable fundamental risk factors.

Which type of investing goal is GPIX typically associated with?

GPIX, with its lower expense ratio of 0.29% and solid yield of 8.07%, is often positioned for investors seeking a balance between moderate income generation and cost efficiency. Its recent inception date of October 2023 means it has limited historical data, but the Goldman Sachs branding may appeal to those wanting institutional backing. It is generally suited for investors who want exposure to the S&P 500 with income enhancement but are cautious about eroding returns with high fees. It fits a goal of cost-conscious income generation within a diversified large-cap portfolio context.

What kind of investor might be drawn to SPYI despite its higher fees?

SPYI is typically associated with investors prioritising maximum current income generation, given its high dividend yield of 11.79%. While the expense ratio of 0.68% is higher, the larger net assets of $12.1 billion and earlier inception date of August 2022 provide a longer operational track record. Investors might be drawn to it if their primary goal is cash flow for living expenses, accepting that the higher fees and potentially capped upside are the cost of obtaining such elevated distributions compared to standard equity funds.

How do the net assets of these ETFs influence market liquidity?

Net assets are a key indicator of a fund's size and potential liquidity. SPYI holds $12.1 billion in net assets, which is more than double the $5.8 billion held by GPIX. Larger asset bases generally correlate with higher trading volumes and tighter bid-ask spreads, making it easier for investors to buy and sell shares without significantly impacting the price. While both funds have substantial adoption, SPYI's size may offer slight practical advantages in terms of ease of trade execution for larger institutional or retail positions in the current market environment.

What is the impact of recent inception dates on market confidence?

GPIX was launched on 24 October 2023, while SPYI began on 30 August 2022. Both are relatively recent entrants to the derivative income market compared to older, established funds. A shorter operational history means less data is available to assess how each fund performs across different market cycles, particularly during high volatility or bear markets. This limitation can create uncertainty for conservative investors who prefer proven track records. However, the rapid asset accumulation for both suggests strong initial market interest in these specific S&P 500 income strategies.

Why are sector weights listed as not available for these funds?

For both GPIX and SPYI, the sector weights are not available in the provided data. Typically, ETFs disclose this information to show exposure to areas like technology or healthcare. Its absence here highlights the opaque nature of some derivative-based strategies where holdings might shift more frequently or where the index methodology is proprietary. Without visible sector weights, investors cannot easily assess concentration risk, such as an overweight position in technology, even though the top holdings suggest heavy tech exposure. This requires careful examination of the fund documents to understand potential sectoral risks.

How do distributions work for derivative income ETFs like these?

Unlike traditional ETFs that pass through corporate dividends, derivative income ETFs like GPIX and SPYI often distribute option premium income. This means their payout schedule can differ and may not align strictly with quarterly corporate dividend dates. The yields of 8.07% and 11.79% respectively reflect these distributions. Investors must verify if these payments are classified as dividends or return of capital, as this affects tax treatment. Understanding the mechanism is practical for anyone using these funds for income, as the source of the cash flow impacts the total economic value delivered to the shareholder.

What should beginners keep in mind when comparing GPIX and SPYI?

Beginners should weigh the fee difference (0.29% vs 0.68%) against the yield difference (8.07% vs 11.79%). Consider whether the extra 3.72% yield in SPYI justifies the higher costs and potential tax implications compared to GPIX. Look at the large overlap in top holdings, which means their equity risks are similar. Finally, acknowledge that both have limited long-term track records and unclear sector weights. This comparison page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice; always conduct independent research or consult a qualified professional before making investment decisions.

GPIX vs SPYI

Two funds, one decision: we compare cost, performance and what each ETF actually holds in September 2026.

Compare Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF (GPIX) and NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF (SPYI). This page outlines how they differ on fees, holdings and dividends, plus how each tracks its market. GPIX charges 0.29%, while SPYI charges 0.68%. Educational content, not financial advice.

Fund Snapshot

Key Fund Metrics

GPIX

Metric

SPYI

0.29%

Expense Ratio

0.68%

8.07%

Dividend Yield

11.79%

$5.82B

Net Assets

$12.13B

496

Holdings

511

Oct 24, 2023

Inception Date

Aug 30, 2022

–

Index Tracked

–

Derivative Income

Fund Category

Derivative Income

GPIX costs about $39.00 less per year for every $10,000 invested.

Shared Top Holdings

Holding	GPIX	SPYI
NVDANVIDIA Corporation	8.11%	8.14%
AAPLApple Inc.	7.58%	7.52%
MSFTMicrosoft Corporation	5.54%	5.65%
AMZNAmazon.com, Inc.	3.79%	3.77%
GOOGLAlphabet Inc.	3.37%	3.09%
AVGOBroadcom Inc.	2.42%	2.52%
MUMicron Technology, Inc.	1.68%	1.67%
METAMeta Platforms, Inc.	1.58%	2.27%
TSLATesla, Inc.	1.57%	1.58%

Discover More Comparisons

GPIX vs JEPI

Compare GPIX and JEPI ETFs. Review expense ratios (0.29% vs 0.35%), net assets ($5.8B vs $45.3B), dividends, and top holdings for informed analysis.

JEPI vs SPYI

Compare JEPI and SPYI ETFs. Analyze expense ratios of 0.35% and 0.68%, dividend yields of 8.09% and 11.79%, plus top holdings and strategy differences.

QQQI vs SPYI

Compare QQQI and SPYI on fees, holdings, and dividends. Both NEOS ETFs have a 0.68% expense ratio. Review performance data and tracking methods.

Investment Analysis

GPIX

Pros

Lower expense ratio of 0.29% compared to Fund B's 0.68% improves net return potential.
Net assets of $5.8 billion indicate substantial investor adoption and operational stability.
High dividend yield of 8.07% provides significant income generation for investors.

Considerations

Index tracked is not available, limiting transparency regarding the specific methodology.
Sector weights are not available, hindering assessment of current sector exposure risks.
Relatively recent inception date of October 2023 means limited long-term performance history.

SPYI

Pros

Larger net assets of $12.1 billion suggest potentially higher liquidity and investor confidence.
Higher dividend yield of 11.79% offers greater income distribution per unit invested.
Slightly earlier inception date of August 2022 allows for marginally longer operational history.

Considerations

Significantly higher expense ratio of 0.68% represents a substantial drag on net returns.
Index tracked is not available, creating opacity in the fund's strategic approach.
Sector weights are not available, preventing a clear understanding of sectoral risk distribution.

About GPIX and SPYI

GPIX (GPIX)

The Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF (GPIX) is designed for investors seeking exposure to the US equity market while generating income. Rather than simply holding the stocks, this fund employs a derivative income strategy, likely using options such as covered calls to enhance yield. This approach aims to balance the potential for share price growth with a significant current income stream. With a dividend yield of 8.07% and a moderate expense ratio of 0.29%, it offers a competitive option for income-focused portfolios. However, investors should be aware that the use of derivatives can sometimes cap upside potential during strong market rallies. Like all investments, capital is at risk, and returns are not guaranteed. It is best suited for those who understand the trade-offs between growth and income generation.

SPYI (SPYI)

The NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF is designed to provide investors with high monthly income by combining exposure to the S&P 500 index with a covered call strategy. This approach aims to generate option premium income to enhance yields, potentially at the cost of limited upside participation during strong bull markets. The fund is actively managed and maintains a large number of holdings to diversify its equity exposure. It may be suitable for investors seeking regular income streams, though high yields often come with increased complexity and different risk profiles compared to traditional index funds. Investors should consider that dividends are not guaranteed, can fluctuate significantly, and may include return of capital, which can erode net asset value over time.

Buy GPIX or SPYI in Nemo

🆓

Zero Commission

Trade stocks, ETFs, and more with zero commission. Keep more of your returns.

🔒

Trusted & Regulated

Part of Exinity Group 2015, serving over a million customers globally.

💰

6% Interest on Cash

Earn 6% AER on uninvested cash with daily interest payments.

GPIX vs SPYI

Fund Snapshot