What does a low expense ratio mean for long-term growth?

An expense ratio is the annual fee charged by a fund to manage your money. For both FDIS and XLY, the expense ratio is 0.08%. This means for every £10,000 invested, £8 is deducted annually. Lower fees generally allow for greater net growth over time because less money is taken from your investments. Since both funds have identical fees, the cost difference is negligible, and you should look at other factors like holdings and assets.

How does ETF liquidity differ between large and small funds?

Liquidity refers to how easily an ETF can be bought or sold without significantly affecting its price. XLY, with net assets of $21.8 billion, typically offers higher trading volumes, which can result in tighter bid-ask spreads and easier execution of large orders. FDIS has $1.7 billion in assets, which is substantial but smaller. While FDIS is still accessible to individual investors, the significantly larger asset base of XLY may provide more robust liquidity for active traders.

Why do FDIS and XLY hold very similar top ten companies?

Both FDIS and XLY track indices focused on the consumer discretionary sector, which includes non-essential goods and services. Because companies like Amazon and Tesla are massive, they dominate most sector indices. Their similar top ten holdings show both funds aim to replicate the same market segment effectively. This overlap suggests the primary differences lie in operational scale and specific index adjustments rather than distinct investment strategies.

Which fund has a longer performance history for analysis?

XLY was launched in December 1998, while FDIS was launched in October 2013. XLY provides a much longer track record, offering more data points for analysing how the fund has behaved through various market cycles, including economic downturns and recoveries. This extensive historical data can be useful for investors who want to see long-term stability. FDIS, being newer, has a shorter historical dataset for review.

How do top holding weights affect risk?

Top holdings represent the largest investments in a fund. Higher weights in specific stocks mean the fund's performance is more sensitive to those companies. XLY holds Amazon at 23.36% and Tesla at 17.79%, showing slightly higher concentration in these two names compared to FDIS. This means if Amazon or Tesla experience significant volatility, XLY might be more impacted than FDIS. Investors often review these figures to understand how concentrated or diversified their exposure is.

What is the consumer discretionary sector?

The consumer discretionary sector includes companies that provide goods and services that are not considered essential. When the economy is strong, individuals spend more on non-essentials, which benefits these companies. The sector often performs differently from the consumer staples sector during economic downturns. Both FDIS and XLY provide broad exposure to this industry, allowing investors to align with consumer spending trends.

How do these funds provide sector diversification?

Both funds track indices focused on the consumer discretionary sector, providing exposure to a wide range of companies within that category. By holding over a hundred companies, they reduce the impact of one single business struggling. This approach is often used to capture sector growth or manage portfolio risk. Investors can hold either fund to diversify their exposure to consumer spending trends without selecting individual stocks.

How are ETF dividends taxed?

Dividends are payments made by companies to shareholders. Both FDIS and XLY collect dividends from their portfolio companies and distribute them to investors. XLY has a slightly higher dividend yield of 0.83% compared to FDIS's 0.79%, meaning for every £10,000 invested, XLY pays £83 annually versus £79 for FDIS before tax. Note that distribution timing and amounts can vary based on the holdings' performance.

How are ETF dividends taxed?

ETFs distribute dividends from their underlying holdings to investors. Taxation depends on your jurisdiction and account type. In the UK, for example, dividends paid within an ISA are generally tax-free, whereas those paid in a general investment account might be subject to income tax. As both funds hold dividend-paying stocks like McDonald's and Procter & Gamble, distributions occur. Consult a tax professional for your specific situation.

How should I compare ETFs for a beginner portfolio?

When comparing ETFs, look at expense ratios, holdings, and fund size. For example, XLY has much higher net assets than FDIS, while FDIS offers similar sector exposure at the same low cost. Beginners should consider how the funds' concentration in top holdings aligns with their risk tolerance. Reviewing data like these helps understand differences without focusing on short-term price changes.

What does sector weight transparency tell us?

Sector weights show how much of a fund is invested in each industry. For FDIS and XLY, sector weights are listed as not available. This means investors cannot directly see how the funds allocate assets across sub-sectors like retail, hotels, or automotive. Instead, you must infer the composition from the top holdings data. Limited transparency requires examining individual companies rather than broad sector breakdowns.

How do I decide which consumer discretionary ETF to invest in?

Investors usually consider factors like expense ratios, fund size, and tracking difference. FDIS and XLY have the same 0.08% expense ratio, but XLY has much higher net assets, which often means tighter spreads. FDIS's top holdings slightly differ, showing less concentration in Amazon and Tesla. If transparency of sector weights is crucial, note they are unavailable for both. Assessing these metrics helps make informed comparisons.

FDIS vs XLY

Two funds, one decision: we compare cost, performance and what each ETF actually holds in September 2026.

Compare FDIS (Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary ETF) and XLY (Consumer Discret Sel Sect SPDR ETF). Both track the consumer discretionary sector with identical 0.08% expense ratios. Review key differences in net assets, dividend yields, top holdings and market tracking methods to understand each fund's structure. Educational content, not financial advice.

Fund Snapshot

Key Fund Metrics

FDIS

Metric

XLY

0.08%

Expense Ratio

0.08%

0.79%

Dividend Yield

0.83%

$1.69B

Net Assets

$21.78B

246

Holdings

Oct 21, 2013

Inception Date

Dec 16, 1998

–

Index Tracked

–

Consumer Cyclical

Fund Category

Consumer Cyclical

Both funds charge the same annual fee.

Shared Top Holdings

Holding	FDIS	XLY
AMZNAmazon.com, Inc.	22.68%	23.36%
TSLATesla, Inc.	16.09%	17.79%
HDThe Home Depot, Inc.	4.72%	5.18%
MCDMcDonald's Corporation	2.79%	4.45%
TJXThe TJX Companies, Inc.	2.23%	3.84%
BKNGBooking Holdings Inc.	2.12%	3.45%
SBUXStarbucks Corporation	1.76%	2.98%
LOWLowe's Companies, Inc.	1.73%	2.95%

Discover More Comparisons

FDIS vs VCR

Compare FDIS and VCR ETFs on fees, holdings, dividends and tracking. Review expense ratios, top assets and fund details for informed research.

FDIS vs VOO

Compare FDIS and VOO on expense ratios, dividend yields, top holdings, and index tracking. Review key differences in fund structure and concentration for this.

FDIS vs FSTA

Compare FDIS and FSTA ETFs on fees, holdings and dividends. Review expense ratios, sector focus and tracking methods for both Fidelity funds today.

Investment Analysis

FDIS

Pros

fdis offers a low expense ratio of 0.08 percent, matching the fee structure of its larger competitor.
the fund provides broad exposure to consumer discretionary companies through a structure that is cost-efficient for investors.
with net assets of 1.7 billion dollars, the fund maintains a substantial asset base for individual investors.

Considerations

fdis holds significantly lower net assets of 1.7 billion dollars compared to its direct competitor xly.
the index tracked by the fund is listed as not available, which may obscure specific methodology details.
sector weights are not available, limiting the transparency of the fund's broader asset allocation strategy.

XLY

Pros

xly manages substantial net assets of 21.8 billion dollars, ensuring high liquidity and trading volume for investors.
the fund has a long track record, having been launched in 1998, providing extensive historical data.
xly offers a slightly higher dividend yield of 0.83 percent compared to the alternative fund option.

Considerations

xly exhibits greater concentration in the top two holdings, with amzn at 23.36 percent and tsla at 17.79 percent.
the index tracked by the fund is listed as not available, obscuring specific index methodology details.
sector weights are not available, limiting the transparency of the fund's broader asset allocation strategy.

Related Market Insights

Beyond 46,000: Investing in a Lower Rate Environment

Explore investment opportunities in rate-sensitive sectors as the Dow surpasses 46,000. Discover how lower interest rates benefit tech, consumer discretionary & finance. Invest with Nemo.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

12 September 2025

Read Insight

Related Market Insights

Beyond 46,000: Investing in a Lower Rate Environment

Explore investment opportunities in rate-sensitive sectors as the Dow surpasses 46,000. Discover how lower interest rates benefit tech, consumer discretionary & finance. Invest with Nemo.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

12 September 2025

Read Insight

About FDIS and XLY

FDIS (FDIS)

FDIS is an exchange-traded fund from Fidelity that seeks to provide exposure to the US consumer discretionary sector by tracking a broad MSCI consumer discretionary index. It holds a diversified basket of companies that sell goods and services tied to consumer spending — from retailers, restaurants and leisure companies to automotive and household discretionary brands. Investors should know this ETF concentrates sector risk: performance is closely linked to consumer confidence, employment and economic cycles, so returns can be more volatile than broad-market funds. FDIS can be useful for adding focused growth exposure or expressing a view on consumer trends, but it does not offer the broad diversification of a total-market ETF. Costs, tracking error and portfolio turnover matter — check the fund prospectus for the current expense ratio, dividend policy and largest holdings. This information is educational, not personal advice; investors should consider their risk tolerance, investment horizon and seek professional guidance if unsure.

XLY (XLY)

XLY (Consumer Discret Sel Sect SPDR ETF) is a sector-focused exchange-traded fund that provides targeted exposure to US consumer discretionary companies — firms in retail, leisure, autos, media and related services. As a sector ETF, it concentrates on businesses whose revenues are sensitive to consumer spending and economic cycles, so it tends to be more growth-oriented and can be more volatile than broad-market funds. Investors use XLY to gain concentrated exposure to trends in retail, e-commerce, travel and durable goods, or to express a view on consumer demand. Because it focuses on a single sector, diversification is limited and performance can swing with the economic cycle. This summary is for educational purposes only and not personalised advice. Consider your investment goals, risk tolerance and the ETF’s suitability for your portfolio; values and income can fall as well as rise.

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Investing Post-46,000: Which Assets May Outperform?

The Dow's historic close above 46,000 was fueled by anticipation of Federal Reserve rate cuts, signaling strong investor confidence. This creates an investment opportunity in sectors that are poised to benefit from a lower interest rate environment.

Published: 12 September 2025

Explore Basket

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Investing Post-46,000: Which Assets May Outperform?

Published: 12 September 2025

Explore Basket

Buy FDIS or XLY in Nemo

🆓

Zero Commission

Trade stocks, ETFs, and more with zero commission. Keep more of your returns.

🔒

Trusted & Regulated

Part of Exinity Group 2015, serving over a million customers globally.

💰

6% Interest on Cash

Earn 6% AER on uninvested cash with daily interest payments.

FDIS vs XLY

Fund Snapshot