What is the primary difference between the DVY and SDY ETFs?

DVY and SDY are both Mid-Cap Value exchange-traded funds targeting dividend-paying companies, but they differ in key metrics. DVY, issued by iShares, launched in Nov 3, 2003, with net assets of $23.1 billion and a dividend yield of 3.40%. In contrast, SDY, from SPDR, was launched in Nov 8, 2005, with net assets of $21.0 billion and a dividend yield of 2.51%. The funds' top holdings also differ, with only VZ and TGT shared among their top ten positions, indicating distinct portfolio strategies. These differences affect risk, return, and suitability for investors' goals. Understanding these aspects helps beginners interpret how similar-category ETFs can vary significantly despite shared objectives.

How do dividend yields affect ETF performance?

A dividend yield measures annual dividend income relative to share price. DVY's yield is 3.40%, while SDY's is 2.51%. Higher yields may indicate stable income but can also reflect different portfolio compositions and risks. These yields don't directly determine total returns, as stock prices also influence performance. Dividend distributions vary by fund policy and are typically paid periodically, not necessarily quarterly. Investors should understand that higher yields can sometimes signal higher risk if not supported by fundamentals. Yield differences between funds highlight how portfolio composition and company selection impact potential income generation.

What are expense ratios and why do they matter?

Expense ratios represent the annual operating fees charged by a fund. DVY's expense ratio is 0.38%, and SDY's is 0.35%. The difference is 0.03%, or three basis points. While seemingly minor, fees compound over time. For example, on a $10,000 investment, this difference amounts to $3 annually, impacting returns over decades. Fees cover fund management, operations, and tracking costs. Lower expense ratios may leave more money compounding within your investment. Investors should understand that while fees are important, they shouldn't be the sole decision factor; they're one component of total cost alongside tracking difference and portfolio quality.

How do the top holdings of DVY and SDY differ?

DVY's top holdings include HPQ at 2.63%, PFE at 2.27%, and PRU at 2.20%. In comparison, SDY's largest positions are VZ at 3.21%, ACN at 3.00%, and CVX at 2.07%. The funds have limited overlap, with only VZ and TGT appearing in both top ten lists. This indicates significant differences in their portfolio construction and stock selection. DVY features more healthcare and financial holdings, while SDY shows greater representation in technology and utilities. Understanding these differences helps investors grasp how fund managers select companies and build dividend portfolios, and how these decisions might influence potential returns and risks.

Which ETF is better for long-term compounding?

This question involves multiple factors beyond simple comparison. DVY has a higher dividend yield at 3.40%, potentially offering more reinvestment income. SDY has a slightly lower expense ratio at 0.35%, allowing more money to remain invested. Neither fund's total return potential can be determined solely from these metrics. The sector composition, market conditions, and management strategies of each fund influence performance. Additionally, their inception dates differ, with DVY having a longer track record since Nov 3, 2003, compared to SDY's Nov 8, 2005. These factors contribute to different risk profiles and growth potential, making a single recommendation inappropriate without considering individual investment objectives and circumstances.

How do these funds generate returns?

Both DVY and SDY generate returns through two main components: capital appreciation and income distributions. Capital appreciation occurs when the underlying stock prices increase. Income distributions come from dividends received from companies in their portfolios, paid out to shareholders. DVY's higher yield of 3.40% reflects greater dividend income, while SDY's 2.51% yield represents more capital growth potential. Their performance differs based on portfolio composition. DVY's top holdings, such as HPQ and PFE, contrast with SDY's larger positions in VZ and ACN. These stock selection differences impact how each fund responds to sector rotations and market conditions. Neither fund's approach is inherently superior; they reflect different strategies for dividend investing.

How are dividend distributions processed in these ETFs?

DVY and SDY distribute dividends periodically, typically paying them to shareholders based on the income collected from their portfolio companies. The frequency might vary by fund policy and market conditions. DVY's current yield of 3.40% represents income relative to its net asset value, while SDY's yield is 2.51%. These figures don't predict future distributions, which depend on company payout decisions and fund income collection. Distributions are usually credited to brokerage accounts or reinvested if automatically enrolled. Investors should consult each fund's specific distribution history and policy, as yields reflect recent past performance and not guaranteed future income. The underlying holdings' dividend policies ultimately drive these cash flows.

How do these ETFs compare in terms of concentration?

Both DVY and SDY are Mid-Cap Value funds targeting dividend-paying companies, but concentration levels differ based on top holdings. DVY's top holding is HPQ at 2.63%, while SDY's is VZ at 3.21%. This suggests SDY has a slightly higher top-position weight. The number of holdings influences concentration; smaller portfolios typically mean greater concentration, but neither fund's total holding count is provided. With only VZ and TGT shared among their top ten, the funds exhibit distinct portfolio strategies. DVY includes companies like MO and TROW, while SDY features ACN and CVX. Understanding concentration helps investors gauge potential single-stock risk, though detailed sector weights aren't available for this analysis.

What does it mean that both funds are Mid-Cap Value?

The Mid-Cap Value classification indicates both DVY and SDY primarily invest in companies of medium size with relatively lower valuation multiples compared to their growth-oriented counterparts. DVY, with $23.1 billion in assets, and SDY, with $21.0 billion, both target this market segment. Mid-cap companies often exhibit characteristics of both large-cap stability and small-cap growth potential. Value stocks typically have higher dividend yields and lower price-to-earnings ratios. Both funds' dividend yields (DVY at 3.40%, SDY at 2.51%) are higher than the broader market average, aligning with the value segment focus. This strategy aims to capture companies perceived to be undervalued but paying steady dividends. The category doesn't guarantee specific performance; it describes the investment approach.

How do these funds perform in different market conditions?

As Mid-Cap Value ETFs, both DVY and SDY may behave differently across various market cycles. Their focus on dividend-paying, potentially undervalued companies suggests they might exhibit relative strength during periods when value factors outperform growth, or when investors favor income. DVY's higher yield (3.40% vs 2.51% for SDY) could attract investors seeking income in low-rate environments. Conversely, during economic recoveries or when growth stocks lead, SDY might outperform due to its portfolio composition, though this depends on individual stock selection. Their inception dates (DVY in Nov 3, 2003, and SDY in Nov 8, 2005) mean they've experienced different market cycles. Neither's specific market conditions are predictable; understanding their composition helps gauge potential behaviour.

What costs should I consider beyond expense ratios?

Beyond DVY's 0.38% and SDY's 0.35% expense ratios, investors should consider transaction costs (commissions and bid-ask spreads) when buying or selling. The funds' net assets of $23.1 billion and $21.0 billion respectively suggest they are well-traded, which typically keeps spreads tighter. Tax implications of distributions also represent a cost; income tax on dividends reduces net returns. Tracking error, the difference between fund and index performance, is another factor, though index tracking information isn't available. Rebalancing within the fund occurs as holdings change (e.g., DVY has HPQ and PFE, while SDY has VZ and ACN), potentially impacting returns. These costs are essential to understanding the fund's true performance.

Can I invest in both funds simultaneously?

Yes, it is possible to hold both DVY and SDY within a single portfolio. Since both are dividend-focused Mid-Cap Value funds, overlapping exposure might occur. They share only VZ and TGT among their top ten holdings, with DVY holding HPQ and PFE and SDY holding ACN and CVX. This low overlap reduces immediate duplication. Investors might choose to hold both to diversify their dividend strategy or to gain broader exposure. This approach requires monitoring performance, distributions, and overall portfolio balance. It's important to note that this isn't a recommendation but an illustration of portfolio construction possibilities. The educational disclaimer for this page applies here as well.

DVY vs SDY

Two funds, one decision: we compare cost, performance and what each ETF actually holds in September 2026.

This page compares the iShares Select Dividend ETF (DVY) and S&P Dividend SPDR (SDY). Examine their fees, holdings, dividend yields and how each fund tracks its market. Both target dividend-paying companies. Educational content, not financial advice.

This page compares the iShares Select Dividend ETF (DVY) and S&P Dividend SPDR (SDY). Examine their fees, holdings, dividend yields and how each fund tracks its market. Both target dividend-paying com...

Fund Snapshot

Key Fund Metrics

DVY

Metric

SDY

0.38%

Expense Ratio

0.35%

3.40%

Dividend Yield

2.51%

$23.05B

Net Assets

$21.00B

104

Holdings

158

Nov 3, 2003

Inception Date

Nov 8, 2005

–

Index Tracked

–

Mid-Cap Value

Fund Category

Mid-Cap Value

SDY costs about $3.00 less per year for every $10,000 invested.

Shared Top Holdings

Holding	DVY	SDY
VZVerizon Communications Inc.	1.83%	3.21%
TGTTarget Corporation	1.74%	1.77%

Discover More Comparisons

DVY vs SCHD

Compare DVY and SCHD ETFs on expense ratios, dividend yields, top holdings, and tracking. Review fees, assets, and inception dates for these dividend funds.

DVY vs VYM

Compare DVY and VYM on fees, holdings and dividends. DVY yields 3.40% at 0.38%, while VYM yields 2.31% at 0.04%. Track metrics to assess alignment.

DVY vs SPYD

Compare DVY and SPYD on fees, holdings and dividends. See expense ratios of 0.38% vs 0.07% and yields of 3.40% vs 4.37% to decide which to research.

Investment Analysis

DVY

Pros

],cons
pros: [
pros: [

Considerations

pros: [
cons: [
cons: [

SDY

Pros

pros: [
pros: [
cons: [

Considerations

cons: [
cons: [
cons: [

Related Market Insights

Fortress Dividends: The Defensive Income Strategy That Actually Works

Discover Fortress Dividends, a defensive strategy for reliable income. Invest in financially robust companies that deliver sustainable dividends through economic storms.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

25 July 2025

Read Insight

The Dividend Champions: Building Your First Investment Paycheck

Generate reliable passive income with Nemo's Dividend Champions Neme. Invest in top dividend stocks like Stellus Capital & BlackRock for a steady investment paycheck.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

25 July 2025

Read Insight

Related Market Insights

Fortress Dividends: The Defensive Income Strategy That Actually Works

Discover Fortress Dividends, a defensive strategy for reliable income. Invest in financially robust companies that deliver sustainable dividends through economic storms.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

25 July 2025

Read Insight

The Dividend Champions: Building Your First Investment Paycheck

Generate reliable passive income with Nemo's Dividend Champions Neme. Invest in top dividend stocks like Stellus Capital & BlackRock for a steady investment paycheck.

Aimee Silverwood | Financial Analyst

25 July 2025

Read Insight

About DVY and SDY

DVY (DVY)

The iShares Select Dividend ETF (DVY) is an exchange-traded fund designed to provide investors with exposure to a portfolio of dividend-paying US equities. Classified within the Mid-Cap Value category, this fund holds approximately 104 companies, focusing on those with a history of consistent dividends. With an expense ratio of 0.38% and net assets of USD 23.05 billion, it offers a relatively accessible entry point for income-focused strategies. The fund currently reports a dividend yield of 3.40%. Launched in November 2003, DVY has established a long track record in the market. Investors should note that while dividends can provide income, the value of the fund and its distributions can fluctuate. As with any investment, past performance is not indicative of future results, and it is important to consider the inherent risks associated with equity markets.

SDY (SDY)

S&P Dividend SPDR (SDY) is an exchange-traded fund that aims to track the S&P High Yield Dividend Aristocrats Index — companies in the broader US market that have increased dividends for many consecutive years. It is designed for investors seeking income from equities rather than capital growth alone, often delivering a higher yield than broad-market ETFs. Holdings can be concentrated in sectors such as utilities, consumer staples and financials, and the fund typically rebalances periodically to maintain index eligibility. Investors should note that dividend payments and yields fluctuate, and capital values can fall as well as rise. Fees, tracking error and tax treatment affect net returns, so check current costs and distributions before investing. This information is general and educational only and not personalised financial advice; assess suitability for your goals and risk tolerance or consult a professional.

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Fortress Dividends

Discover companies with rock-solid financial foundations that deliver stable, dependable dividend income. These carefully selected stocks have been chosen by our investment experts for their ability to provide reliable payouts while maintaining strong balance sheets.

Published: 17 June 2025

Explore Basket

First Paycheck

Get paid to invest with this collection of dividend champions. These carefully selected companies have proven track records of sharing profits with shareholders, creating a reliable stream of income that feels like receiving a regular paycheck from your investments.

Published: 17 June 2025

Explore Basket

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Fortress Dividends

Discover companies with rock-solid financial foundations that deliver stable, dependable dividend income. These carefully selected stocks have been chosen by our investment experts for their ability to provide reliable payouts while maintaining strong balance sheets.

Published: 17 June 2025

Explore Basket

First Paycheck

Get paid to invest with this collection of dividend champions. These carefully selected companies have proven track records of sharing profits with shareholders, creating a reliable stream of income that feels like receiving a regular paycheck from your investments.

Published: 17 June 2025

Explore Basket

DVY vs SDY

Fund Snapshot