Safety Insurance vs Peoples Bancorp

Safety Insurance and Peoples Bancorp are presented on this page to compare business models, financial performance, and market context. The aim is to be neutral and accessible, offering clear context on both organisations for readers evaluating options. Educational content, not financial advice.

Safety Insurance and Peoples Bancorp are presented on this page to compare business models, financial performance, and market context. The aim is to be neutral and accessible, offering clear context o...

Comparison Snapshot

Key Financial Metrics

SAFT

Metric

PEBO

$1.11B

Market Cap

$1.13B

N/A

Potential Profit

2.33%

N/A

Analyst Rating

Hold

Investment Analysis

Safety Insurance

SAFT

Pros

Safety Insurance Group reported improved profitability with a combined ratio of 98.9% in Q3 2025, reflecting effective underwriting and pricing discipline.
The company delivered strong top-line growth, with net written premiums up 5.7% and net earned premiums up 12.5% year-on-year, driven by rate increases and policy count growth.
Safety Insurance maintains a robust dividend yield above 4.5% and has resumed share repurchases, supporting shareholder returns and confidence.

Considerations

The company's return on equity remains below industry averages, raising concerns about long-term capital efficiency and profitability sustainability.
Safety Insurance's valuation metrics, including a price-to-earnings ratio above sector peers, suggest shares may be overextended relative to fundamentals.
Its business is heavily concentrated in Massachusetts, exposing it to regional regulatory and economic risks that could impact growth and profitability.

Peoples Bancorp

PEBO

Pros

Peoples Bancorp operates with a diversified financial services model, offering banking, insurance, and trust solutions across multiple markets.
The company maintains a stable net interest margin and consistent loan growth, supported by a strong regional deposit base and prudent credit management.
Peoples Bancorp has a history of steady dividend payments and moderate capital deployment, appealing to income-focused investors.

Considerations

The company faces exposure to regional economic fluctuations, which can affect loan demand and asset quality in its core markets.
Peoples Bancorp's growth is limited by its smaller scale compared to national peers, constraining expansion opportunities and economies of scale.
Net interest income is sensitive to interest rate changes, creating potential volatility in earnings during periods of monetary policy shifts.

About The Companies

Safety Insurance (SAFT)

Safety Insurance Group Inc (SAFT) is a regional property and casualty insurer with a market capitalisation around $1.04 billion. It primarily underwrites personal lines such as private passenger auto and homeowners insurance, operating largely in the Northeastern US. Investors should know Safety’s results are driven by underwriting performance (premiums, loss ratios and reserve adequacy) and investment income from its balance sheet. The stock can be sensitive to weather-related catastrophe losses, reserve development and competitive pricing in its markets, as well as broader interest-rate and market moves that affect investment returns. As a mid-cap insurer, it offers potential exposure to steady premium income and underwriting leverage but comes with sector-specific risks and earnings volatility. This summary is educational and not personalised advice; prospective investors should review the company’s latest regulatory filings, financial statements and analyst reports, and consider how an insurance stock fits their risk profile and investment horizon.

Peoples Bancorp (PEBO)

Peoples Bancorp Inc. is a diversified financial services holding company operating primarily in the American Midwest and Mid-Atlantic regions. Through its main subsidiary, Peoples Bank, it offers a comprehensive suite of commercial and consumer banking services. These include various types of deposit accounts, loans, and home equity lines of credit. Beyond traditional banking, the company has expanded its offerings to include trust and investment services, insurance products, and equipment financing and leasing solutions. This broad portfolio allows it to serve a wide range of customers, from individuals to businesses. With a network of approximately 129 full-service branches across states like Ohio, Kentucky, and Virginia, alongside a robust online and mobile banking presence, Peoples Bancorp focuses on accessibility and community-based financial services. As with any investment, the value can go down as well as up, and returns are not guaranteed.

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Property & Casualty Insurance Momentum Play

This carefully selected group of stocks captures the potential upside across the property and casualty insurance sector. Professional analysts have identified these companies following Travelers' impressive earnings report, suggesting similar strength may benefit other disciplined insurers with solid underwriting practices.

Published: July 20, 2025

Explore Basket

Caregiver Brands

These companies have built their reputations on protection, trust, and reliability. Carefully selected by our analysts, they provide essential, non-discretionary services that customers consistently need, creating resilient business models with loyal customer bases.

Published: June 17, 2025

Explore Basket

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Property & Casualty Insurance Momentum Play

This carefully selected group of stocks captures the potential upside across the property and casualty insurance sector. Professional analysts have identified these companies following Travelers' impressive earnings report, suggesting similar strength may benefit other disciplined insurers with solid underwriting practices.

Published: July 20, 2025

Explore Basket

Caregiver Brands

These companies have built their reputations on protection, trust, and reliability. Carefully selected by our analysts, they provide essential, non-discretionary services that customers consistently need, creating resilient business models with loyal customer bases.

Published: June 17, 2025

Explore Basket

Discover More Comparisons

New Mountain Finance vs Peoples Bancorp

OceanFirst vs Peoples Bancorp

OceanFirst Financial Corp vs Peoples Bancorp Inc

Safety Insurance vs Peoples Bancorp

Comparison Snapshot