Oppenheimer vs Heritage Insurance

Oppenheimer and Heritage Insurance Holdings are compared on business models, financial performance, and market context. This page presents neutral, accessible analysis of how each company operates and the broader market environment they navigate. Educational content, not financial advice.

Oppenheimer and Heritage Insurance Holdings are compared on business models, financial performance, and market context. This page presents neutral, accessible analysis of how each company operates and...

Comparison Snapshot

Key Financial Metrics

OPY

Metric

HRTG

$844.59M

Market Cap

$793.50M

N/A

Potential Profit

36.91%

N/A

Analyst Rating

Buy

Investment Analysis

Oppenheimer

OPY

Pros

Revenue increased by 13.7% year-over-year in Q3 2025 to $424.4 million, driven by higher investment banking revenues amid favourable capital market conditions.
Insider ownership is high at 43.61%, suggesting strong management alignment with shareholders.
The company maintains a solid financial position with a quick ratio of 3.03, indicating good short-term liquidity.

Considerations

Net income declined from $24.5 million in Q3 2024 to $21.7 million in Q3 2025 due to higher pre-tax compensation expenses related to stock awards.
Free cash flow has been volatile with significant fluctuations over recent periods, indicating potential operational cash flow instability.
Market valuation metrics such as P/FCF ratio are relatively high at 26.71, which could imply overvaluation risks relative to cash flow.

Heritage Insurance

HRTG

Pros

Heritage Insurance Holdings serves a diversified regional property and casualty insurance market, providing a range of personal and commercial insurance products.
The company's regional focus may allow for better market penetration and tailored risk management compared to national insurers.
Insurance sector exposure provides potential for stable, recurring premium revenues, benefiting from cyclical but essential insurance demand.

Considerations

As a regional insurer, Heritage may face competitive pressures and economic fluctuations affecting claims and profitability more acutely than larger, diversified insurers.
Property and casualty insurance is cyclical and sensitive to catastrophic events, potentially causing earnings volatility.
Limited publicly available recent financial detail highlights a need for further transparency to assess current performance dynamics comprehensively.

About The Companies

Oppenheimer (OPY)

Oppenheimer Holdings (ticker: OPY) is a US-based independent investment bank and wealth manager offering advisory, capital markets, trading and wealth management services to individuals, institutions and corporations. With a market capitalisation around $720.13M, the firm is notable for its focus on personalised client services, middle-market M&A and equity underwriting, alongside a growing private client business. Revenue and profitability can be cyclical and sensitive to market volatility, interest rates and deal activity — factors that typically drive investment banking fees and trading income. Regulatory oversight and competition from larger global banks are ongoing considerations. For investors, OPY may appeal as a specialised, cyclical financial services exposure, but it carries risks typical of smaller-cap broker-dealers, including earnings variability and liquidity constraints. This summary is educational only and not personal advice; investors should consider their objectives, risk tolerance and do further research before acting.

Heritage Insurance (HRTG)

Heritage Insurance Holdings (HRTG) is a small-cap property and casualty insurer with a focus on homeowners policies in hurricane- and storm-exposed regions. With a market capitalisation around $709m, the company’s results are driven by premium growth, claims experience after major weather events, reinsurance costs and investment income. Investors should watch underwriting margins and reserve adequacy: insurance profitability depends on accurate pricing and sufficient reserves for catastrophes. Regulatory developments and state-level insurance rules can materially affect operations in its core markets. The stock can be more volatile than larger insurers because of concentrated geographic exposure and smaller capital buffers. That said, improvements in underwriting discipline or favourable reinsurance terms can meaningfully improve returns. This summary provides general, educational information and is not personalised investment advice; insurance stocks carry specific risks and past performance is not a guide to future results.

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Navigating Fed Independence Under Pressure

The President's removal of a Federal Reserve governor creates unprecedented uncertainty around the central bank's independence. This theme identifies companies that could benefit from the resulting market volatility and increased focus on financial compliance.

Published: August 28, 2025

Explore Basket

Capitalizing on the IPO Boom

A collection of carefully selected stocks that stand to benefit from the surging IPO market. Our professional analysts have identified the financial firms, exchanges, and investment banks that facilitate and profit from this increased capital raising activity.

Published: July 2, 2025

Explore Basket

Which Baskets Do They Appear In?

Navigating Fed Independence Under Pressure

The President's removal of a Federal Reserve governor creates unprecedented uncertainty around the central bank's independence. This theme identifies companies that could benefit from the resulting market volatility and increased focus on financial compliance.

Published: August 28, 2025

Explore Basket

Capitalizing on the IPO Boom

A collection of carefully selected stocks that stand to benefit from the surging IPO market. Our professional analysts have identified the financial firms, exchanges, and investment banks that facilitate and profit from this increased capital raising activity.

Published: July 2, 2025

Explore Basket

Discover More Comparisons

Oppenheimer vs Nuveen Select Tax-Free Income Portfolio

Oppenheimer vs Vinci Compass

Oppenheimer vs PIMCO Access Income Fund

Oppenheimer vs Heritage Insurance

Comparison Snapshot