Hess Midstream vs Murphy USA
Hess Midstream collects, processes, and transports crude oil, natural gas, and water in the Bakken shale with stable fee-based contracts anchored by Hess Corporation; Murphy USA operates high-volume fuel stations and convenience stores at Walmart locations and freestanding sites across the Sun Belt. Hess Midstream vs Murphy USA pairs a midstream MLP with predictable cash flows and a high distribution yield against a high-velocity fuel retailer that generates strong returns on capital through low-cost, high-throughput fuel sales and growing convenience store economics. Both offer income-oriented investors attractive cash generation but through very different infrastructure and retail models. Readers'll compare fee contract quality, distribution growth rates, capital spending requirements, leverage, and the long-term competitive dynamics shaping each company's future.
Hess Midstream collects, processes, and transports crude oil, natural gas, and water in the Bakken shale with stable fee-based contracts anchored by Hess Corporation; Murphy USA operates high-volume f...
Investment Analysis
Hess Midstream
HESM
Pros
- Hess Midstream reported strong and growing net income with Q2 2025 income increasing to $179.7 million, driven by volume growth across gas processing, oil terminaling, and water gathering segments.
- The company increased its quarterly cash distribution consistently, with a 5% annual distribution growth guidance through 2027, supported by strong adjusted free cash flow.
- Chevron owns a significant 37.8% indirect stake following the Hess acquisition, providing strategic backing and stability to Hess Midstream’s operations and growth prospects.
Considerations
- Growth plans face headwinds due to Chevron's reduction of Bakken rig activity, impacting future throughput volumes and prompting some analyst downgrades.
- Revenue expectations for 2025 have been adjusted downward by around 2%, reflecting market and operational uncertainties in key shale regions.
- Despite strong cash flow, capital expenditures remain substantial to support compression and pipeline infrastructure expansion, involving execution risks and cost pressures.
Murphy USA
MUSA
Pros
- Murphy USA benefits from strong downstream retail fuel demand and a broad convenience store network with strategic presence in growing U.S. markets.
- Its focus on convenience retail and fuel operations provides diversified revenue streams, helping it navigate fuel price volatility and economic cycles effectively.
- The company has demonstrated consistent profitability and positive cash flow generation, supporting its ability to sustain dividends and reinvest in growth initiatives.
Considerations
- Murphy USA's profitability is closely tied to fuel price fluctuations and refining margins, exposing it to commodity price risks and regulatory changes.
- As a fuel retailer, the company faces increasing competition from alternative energy retailers and evolving consumer preferences towards electric vehicles.
- Economic downturns and shifts in transportation patterns can negatively impact fuel demand and in-store sales, potentially reducing revenue and cash flow.
Buy HESM or MUSA in Nemo
Zero Commission
Trade stocks, ETFs, and more with zero commission. Keep more of your returns.
Trusted & Regulated
Part of Exinity Group 2015, serving over a million customers globally.
6% Interest on Cash
Earn 6% AER on uninvested cash with daily interest payments.
