Amerant vs Donegal Group

Amerant Bancorp Inc and Donegal Group Inc are presented here in a neutral comparison. This page examines business models, financial performance, and market context to help readers understand how Amerant Bancorp Inc and Donegal Group Inc fit within the sector. The goal is clear, accessible analysis without recommendations or forecasts. Educational content, not financial advice.

Comparison Snapshot

Key Financial Metrics

AMTB

Metric

DGICA

$840.58M

Market Cap

$688.71M

-0.46%

Potential Profit

13.09%

Buy

Analyst Rating

Buy

Investment Analysis

Amerant

AMTB

Pros

Amerant Bancorp operates with a $738 million market capitalization classified as a small-cap, indicating growth potential in the finance sector.
The company reported $305 million in trailing twelve months revenue with a net profit margin above 17%, showing solid profitability.
Amerant has a return on equity of 14.9%, demonstrating efficient shareholder return and reasonable operational management.

Considerations

Quarterly results showed a significant drop in net income from $23 million to $14.8 million, impacted by a higher-than-expected provision for credit losses.
The company’s earnings per share missed analyst expectations substantially in Q3 2025, with a 31% shortfall compared to forecasted EPS.
Amerant has a high debt-to-equity ratio above 100%, indicating a leveraged balance sheet which could increase financial risk.

Donegal Group

DGICA

Pros

Donegal Group is a well-established property and casualty insurer with consistent underwriting profitability in a competitive market.
The company has a diversified product portfolio including business, personal, and specialty insurance lines that support stable revenue streams.
Donegal maintains a strong balance sheet with good capitalisation ratios that support consistent dividend payments and growth investments.

Considerations

Exposure to natural catastrophe losses and severe weather events introduces volatility risks to underwriting results and earnings.
The insurance industry faces regulatory and litigation risks that could impact Donegal’s operational costs and profitability.
Slower industry-wide premium rate increases sometimes pressure revenue growth and margins in Donegal’s core markets.

About The Companies

Amerant (AMTB)

Amerant Bancorp Inc. is a bank holding company operating through its main subsidiary, Amerant Bank. It offers a comprehensive suite of financial services to individuals, businesses, and high-net-worth clients. These services include standard retail and commercial banking, such as deposits and credit, alongside more specialised offerings like wealth management, investment products, and fiduciary services. For affluent customers, Amerant provides sophisticated trust and estate planning solutions. The company has embraced digital banking, offering a full range of online and mobile services, which complements its traditional branch-based operations. For investors, Amerant represents a company with deep roots in the financial services industry, attempting to blend traditional banking with modern convenience. As with any financial institution, its performance can be influenced by economic conditions and interest rate changes. The value of investments can go down as well as up.

Donegal Group (DGICA)

Donegal Group Inc. is an American insurance holding company that operates through its various subsidiaries. The firm provides property and casualty insurance, which covers assets like homes and cars, and protects against legal liability. Its business is split into two main insurance divisions: personal lines, offering products like private car and homeowner policies, and commercial lines, which include commercial car insurance, multi-peril policies, and workers' compensation. The company distributes its insurance products through a wide network of approximately 2,100 independent agencies across several regions in the United States. For investors, Donegal Group represents a company with a focused presence in the property and casualty insurance market. As with any investment, it's important to remember that share values can go down as well as up, and returns are not guaranteed.

Buy AMTB or DGICA in Nemo

🆓

Zero Commission

Trade stocks, ETFs, and more with zero commission. Keep more of your returns.

🔒

Trusted & Regulated

Part of Exinity Group 2015, serving over a million customers globally.

💰

6% Interest on Cash

Earn 6% AER on uninvested cash with daily interest payments.

Discover More Comparisons

Amerant vs Metropolitan Bank

Amerant vs Columbia Seligman Premium Technology Growth Fund

Amerant v Columbia Seligman Premium Technology Growth Fund

Amerant vs Donegal Group

Comparison Snapshot